The Old Sun Inn Keighley Menu

Let’s be honest—most pub menus are a bit of a gamble, aren’t they? You walk in, cross your fingers, and hope the “homemade” pie didn’t arrive in a cardboard box. The Old Sun Inn in Keighley is not that kind of place.

Think of that one reliable friend who always brings a proper lasagne to the potluck. That’s the vibe here. The menu feels like it was written by someone who actually enjoys feeding people, not just shuffling plates out of a kitchen.

Sunday roasts that feel like a hug

You know that Sunday roast you dream about all week? The Old Sun Inn’s version is the headliner. The Yorkshire puddings are so tall and golden, they practically wave at you from the plate.

And the gravy? It’s not some watery afterthought. It’s thick, rich, and—dare I say—soul-warming. It’s the kind of gravy you want to bottle and take home for a rainy Tuesday. Trust a local when they say, “Get the beef.”

Starters that set the mood

If you’re anything like me, you start planning your dessert before the main course arrives. But you’ll want to linger on the starters here. The garlic mushrooms come in a creamy, herby sauce that’s good enough to mop up with bread.

There’s also a black pudding scotch egg that will ruin standard scotch eggs for you forever. Seriously. It’s crispy on the outside, soft in the middle, and has that peppery kick you never knew you needed.

THE 10 BEST Restaurants & Places to Eat in Haworth 2025

Pub classics done right

Let’s talk about the fish and chips. The batter is light and crisp, not that sad, greasy blanket you sometimes get. The chips are chunky, the peas are proper mushy, and there’s a little lemon wedge that makes you feel like a grown-up.

Meanwhile, the beef and ale pie arrives in its own dish. Lift the pastry lid, and steam rises like a tiny volcano of beefy, herby goodness. You want this on a cold, rainy Tuesday.

Vegetarians and picky eaters, welcome

You know the struggle: going out with one friend who “doesn’t eat meat” and another who “only likes plain things.” The Old Sun Inn’s menu has both covered. The butternut squash risotto is creamy and cozy, while the halloumi burger is salty, squeaky, and satisfying.

Even the kid’s menu plays it smart—think mini sausages and cheesy pasta, but done with the same love as the adult dishes. No sad, beige nuggets here.

THE OLD SUN HOTEL (Keighley, Inglaterra) - opiniones y comentarios

Desserts that earn the extra fork

By this point, you’re full. You’re leaning back in your chair. You’re unbuttoning your jeans. Then the server says, “Sticky toffee pudding with custard?” and suddenly you have room.

The sticky toffee pudding is a legend. It’s dense, sweet, and drenched in a caramel sauce that tastes like a hug from a candy shop. The chocolate brownie is just as dangerous—gooey in the middle, with vanilla ice cream melting into it.

Why you should care

Look, we all need a place where the food feels like a reward, not a chore. The Old Sun Inn gives you that “I’m treating myself” feeling without any stuffy atmosphere or silly prices.

It’s the kind of menu that turns a Tuesday dinner into a mini-celebration. So next time you’re in Keighley, skip the chain pubs. Go to the Old Sun Inn, order the roast, and let the gravy do the talking. Your belly will thank you.